For years, Ethiopia's mining sector sparked economic opportunity while despoiling lands. A new study suggests its legacy may prove even more corrosive unless changes are made. Through interviews across the country's gold fields and beyond, BirrMetrics discovered haphazard use of cyanide and mercury tainting soil and water sources alike. With contamination continuing unchecked and the informal sector rife with these dangerous substances, today's prosperity risks bequeathing future generations an indelible inheritance of poison instead of plenty.
A new investigation by BirrMetrics has shone a light on the informal and unregulated use of dangerous chemicals in Ethiopia's mining sector, leading to severe environmental damage. Both small-scale artisanal miners and large commercial operations are employing toxic substances like cyanide and mercury without proper oversight, according to interviews with regional authorities.
The illegal trade in mining chemicals is also prevalent. Officials in Tigray province recently intercepted 40kg of smuggled mercury, though the shipment's source and intended destination went untraced after the substance vanished from government warehouses. Chinese involvement in mercury trafficking was noted.
Widespread application of cyanide and mercury, especially, has been witnessed cross mining regions. Larger firms initially import toxins legally before distributing them via collector networks to artisanal prospectors in surrounding areas.
As an anonymous Benishangul official told BirrMetrics, mining companies act not just as producers but also purchasers of gold, supplying chemicals to small-scale miners near firm sites. Artisanal miners then process gold using the toxins before selling back to companies and collectors.
The unchecked release of contaminants into soils and waterways poses acute public health and environmental hazards. Yet officers investigating such problems also risk retaliation.
The use of mercury and cyanide in small-scale gold mining is ravaging Ethiopia's environment, with long-lasting consequences, an official of Oromia region said. While banned internationally, these chemicals remain widely and illegally used domestically to "expedite gold extraction," according to an official at the Oromia Mining Development Authority. But their impact on soil, water, flora, fauna and human health is severe and sometimes irreversible. Traces linger for "generations, staining the land."
Most alarming is that artisanal miners now have direct access to these toxins. Large foreign and domestic companies operating in Ethiopia's gold sector import and supply the chemicals, using artisanal outfits to supplement their own production—an underhanded arrangement that flouts rules while fuelling contamination.
Beyond chemicals, "usually open spits are left without redevelopment. Then the open spit is filled with rainwater. The water then brings unwanted diseases like malaria," said the Oromia official. There are also cases where "important plant varieties, and also cash crops, are wiped out to give way for mining," they added. Communities near Legedembi bear the scars: the official showed this magazine pictures of "children with deformed legs, and affected skins."
Concerns about environmental degradation in Ethiopia's gold mines are gaining substance, as a recent report sheds light on contamination near one of its largest mining projects.
The Consortium of Ethiopian Human Rights Organizations, in its study of Midroc Legedembi Gold's operations, found "air, water and soil" around the site to be polluted with toxins like mercury and cyanide above safe levels. This poses risks to locals' health, livelihoods and wildlife.
CEHRO's findings follow its investigations into complaints against other mines and agricultural ventures, including accusations of communities displaced without compensation. They highlight the difficulties of balancing development and rights in a sector where informal operations dominate.
With previous analyses also flagging toxic residues, CEHRO is pushing for an independent audit. This would determine the "type and standard" of chemicals used by Midroc as well as smaller miners - an important step to understand impacts.
CEHRO's uncovering of higher respiratory illness and birth defects where Legedembi operates compounds local frustrations. Communities have long borne the health costs of contamination without redress, the report suggests.
Its findings echo prior work, emphasising the need for transparency. Yet assessments of Harms have reportedly been kept under wraps, denying citizens data to demand remedies for pollution-linked problems.
Government officials and Midroc executives defend the company's tax and funding contributions as sufficient. But as evidence of toxicity and its impacts on residents mounts, such financial duties appear an insufficient balm for those living with the consequences of lax oversight.
Meeting legal requirements does not preclude further action to independently investigate complaints and support affected communities. Unless all study results are published and accountability ensured, mining's rewards will continue accruing to companies while locals shoulder the risks alone.
A variety of assessments around Midroc Legedembi Gold's operations have reportedly been left undisclosed, according to the CEHRO. Studies mentioned include an environmental review by Addis Ababa University's (AAU) business school, community health evaluations by the Ethiopian Public Health Institute (EPHI) and Ministry of Mines, as well as research from Bule Hora University and Dilla University. Also kept under wraps is a memorandum of understanding between Midroc and the Oromia Mining Development Authority (Oromia MDA), CEHRO contends.
This lack of transparency denies locals information that could help address issues, CEHRO argues. Its report notes communities near the mine have experienced higher respiratory diseases and birth defects without remedy for pollution exposure. Prior investigations by organizations such as EPHI and Oromia MDA similarly noted deteriorating health trends over time in the area.
Full disclosure of results from AAU, EPHI, the universities and other assessments could have facilitated more productive public dialogue on impacts and solutions. With mining projects promising economic gains, temporary jobs do little to offset enduring health burdens shouldered by populations. Initial health reviews also risk becoming superficial without open follow-through and accountability.
Officials from the Ministry of Mines and the Oromia Mining Development Authority (Oromia MDA), as well as Midroc Legedembi Gold executives based in Addis Ababa and Shakiso, maintain the company is fulfilling required financial duties, including community development fund (CDF) contributions under Ethiopian law.
Some Midroc officials and Oromia MDA representatives argue mercury and cyanide traces found in Guji trace to past usage, not current practices. They note Legedembi Gold has operated since Ethiopia's imperial era, and Midroc acquired it after privatization by the Ethiopian People's Revolutionary Democratic Front (EPRDF) government in 1997. Officials claim residues can remain for decades, though Midroc no longer deploys the chemicals.
Experts recommend stringent regulatory frameworks over import, production and application of toxins like cyanide and mercury by government bodies such as the Ministry and Oromia MDA. Ensuring post-mining site rehabilitation is also advised. But to fund remediation and compensate locals adequately, proper CDF collection and allocation by mining firms is key.
Most importantly, experts stress introducing environmental auditing by impartial auditors to identify remedial needs, as well as gauge pollution's economic impacts on GDP. This could help resolve conflicting claims and guide durable solutions for communities.
