Fitch Ratings has triggered backlash from the African Peer Review Mechanism (APRM) after downgrading Afreximbank over sovereign loans to Ghana, Zambia and South Sudan—an action the APRM says is based on flawed assumptions that misrepresent the legal and financial structure of the bank’s operations.
The APRM has issued a scathing rebuke of Fitch’s recent decision to lower the African Export-Import Bank’s (Afreximbank) long-term foreign currency issuer default rating from 'BBB' to 'BBB-', assigning it a negative outlook. In a statement released on 8 June, the African Union-affiliated body accused Fitch of misclassifying certain sovereign loans as non-performing, a move it claims undermines the legal foundations of African multilateral finance.
According to Fitch’s 4 June rating note, the downgrade was driven by concerns over Afreximbank’s risk management, transparency, and rising sovereign exposure. The agency cited an elevated non-performing loan (NPL) ratio—estimated at 7.1 percent by year-end 2024, above its 6 percent high-risk threshold—as justification for the rating action.
However, Afreximbank’s own disclosures reported a much lower NPL figure of 2.44 percent , excluding sovereign exposures to Ghana, Zambia and South Sudan, which the bank considers performing.
The APRM, which monitors credit ratings under a 2020 African Union mandate, described Fitch’s methodology as “analytically and legally flawed,” arguing that the sovereign loans in question are backed by a binding multilateral treaty and should not be assessed using commercial banking norms.
“It is legally incongruent to classify a loan to member countries as non-performing, especially when the borrower states are shareholders in the lender institution, no formal default has occurred, and none of the sovereigns have repudiated the obligation,” the APRM stated.
Afreximbank was established in 1993 through a treaty signed by African states and enjoys preferred creditor status in many jurisdictions. This multilateral framework, the APRM said, provides a unique credit safeguard not adequately reflected in Fitch’s downgrade decision.
Fitch acknowledged that its assessment differs from the bank’s internal reporting, particularly in its application of IFRS 9 accounting standards. It also pointed to a decline in Afreximbank’s disclosure practices relative to peer development finance institutions and cited governance concerns—specifically, the influence of borrower-shareholders on lending decisions.
While Fitch noted that the bank maintains strong capital buffers and collateralisation, it expressed concern over growing exposure to distressed sovereign borrowers, which it argued could eventually lead to credit losses—particularly if those loans are included in broader sovereign debt restructurings.
Afreximbank, whose mission is to boost intra-African trade and industrialisation, has been a key countercyclical lender during the COVID-19 pandemic and recent debt crises. Its largest shareholders include Egypt and Nigeria, and it is often among the first institutions to extend emergency financing to countries facing liquidity shortages.
The APRM’s intervention reflects mounting frustration among African institutions over perceived inconsistencies in how global rating agencies assess African multilaterals. It called on Fitch to “re-examine its criteria and assumptions” and engage in direct technical consultations with Afreximbank and regional stakeholders.
“This downgrade does not only misrepresent the bank’s credit profile; it risks destabilising confidence in Africa’s financial architecture at a time when multilateral institutions like Afreximbank are most needed,” the APRM warned.
As pressure mounts, the controversy is likely to reignite calls for a more equitable global credit rating regime—one that takes into account the unique legal and developmental mandates of African financial institutions.
