One commodity that has proven resistant to reform in Ethiopia is the illicit gold trade. While the government's float of the birr in August narrowed the gap between official and black market exchange rates from a staggering 98% to less than 10%, illegal gold flows remain substantial.
For years, the National Bank of Ethiopia (NBE) was the sole authorised purchaser and exporter of gold in the country. It bought supply from artisanal miners at prices up to 65 percent above monthly international rates in a bid to generate much-needed foreign exchange. However, this carried an annual loss of over 10 billion birr as miners turned to the more lucrative black market instead.
With the official birr/dollar rate fixed at 57, the NBE's hefty premiums still left it over 40 percent below parallel market levels of 110-115 birr to the dollar. Yet since the float, while official and black market currency rates have converged, the incentives for smuggling gold out of the country endure. Much of the supply is thought to end up in Dubai's jewellery shops after transiting through porous borders.
In late August, the NBE issued new guidelines in an attempt to stem flows into the unofficial economy. It declared international forex rates would henceforth set domestic gold prices rather than an additional margin. Yet without room to outbid black market buyers, would miners now supply legally? The directive offers larger-scale producers incentives to sell over 250kg in one transaction. It also allows suppliers to use half their forex proceeds for three months and receive 95 percent of payments upfront, with the remainder in 30 days.
According to a Benishangul mining official, black market gold prices in Ethiopia remain well above the official rate set by the National Bank of Ethiopia (NBE), dampening the impact of August's currency float.
"Today illegal traders pay 9,800 birr per gram, up from 6,300 before the float when the official dollar rate was fixed. But the NBE only offers between 5,100-5,200 birr per gram depending on purity," he said.
The official explained that contraband networks prefer dealing in dollars, shunning the birr. A 3,000-5,000 birr discount entices miners to sidestep the NBE. Some deliberately sell harvested gold under 50g to the bank, saving any excess for the parallel market. With no system to aggregate small deposits, the NBE misses out on repeat business.
An anonymous mining sector investor said the new framework could do more to bring supply into the regulated market. "Allowing exporters in special economic zones to fully utilize forex earnings for three months sets a precedent the NBE should follow. Withholding five percent of payment also lacks commercial logic."
Veteran geologist Wodaje Abebe said more is needed for the formal gold market to compete. "Incentives in the informal system still far outweigh what the government offers. Margins must narrow before flows can be curbed," he stated.
Tigray Bureau mining director Fisaha Miresa said officials have urged the NBE to reconsider. "Miners tell us they work for profit. Unless you reduce the gap between informal and official prices, they will supply the black market," he explained.
Previously, the NBE purchased gold by adding a 65 percent premium to monthly international prices. This was raised from five percent in recent years to match booming black market rates averaging 110-115 birr to the dollar before the float. However, without margins permitted under the new regime, the NBE cannot outbid illegal buyers.
Improved supplies in 2020-21 followed the NBE upping its premium to 35 percent, from five percent under the previous administration. But as black market prices surge, miners revert to selling off-ledger when 100 percent premiums beckon. Raising premiums to 65 percent proved insufficient, indicating more tune is needed for reforms to bear fruit.
The NBE has historically purchased gold at a loss in birr terms due to adding premiums above global prices. This saw it burn nearly 10 billion birr annually to generate much-needed forex for the government. However, without margins permitted after the float, gold flows risk drying up further.
Experts argue alternative incentives beyond price adjustments are still available. "Allowing suppliers to retain 100 percentof export proceeds, not 50 percent, could lure them away from black market buyers," says one mining consultant.
Another recommends support for artisanal miners is vital. "While commercial projects receive tax holidays and infrastructure backing, those digging by hand lack capital, machinery and safe working conditions," they note. Yet it is these miners who produce the most, with no official assistance.
In a worrying trend, sources say artisanal miners across Ethiopia are increasingly getting support from illicit gold network operators. Foreigners and domestic businessmen are covertly supplying equipment, technology and working capital to miners - who then sell harvested gold back to their financiers.
With the government providing minimal assistance, these black market actors have stepped into the gap. "Miners get skills training, detectors, washers and chemicals from contraband rings the state has failed to assist with," one expert told us.
Creating NBE purchase points closer to mining areas is insufficient on its own, argues mining lawyer Wondemagegnehu Gebre-Sellassie. Fundamental legislative reforms are required to strengthen an oversight regime currently hamstrung by "loopholes".
Ethiopia is overhauling its mining law, but more may be needed to curb the underground economy from crowding out the state. Policymakers would do well to learn from how illicit actors have efficiently supplied miners - and cut out middlemen by directly assisting artisanal diggers themselves. Only then can the country optimally harness revenues from its gold-rich lands. Formalisation efforts risk foundering without supporting all links in the resource chain.
